This past week at the House His Eminence Metropolitan Jonah, head of the Orthodox Church in America; Archbishop Duncan, head of the Anglican Church in North America; and many more Orthodox and Anglican priests converged to discuss the hope of a future Orthodox and Anglican reunion. The conference aside it was an amazing time for me because I got to be around a bunch of other Orthodox, and I felt much less out of place. It was really edifying to be with Orthodox priests, and see the joy on their face as their shared my joy at being chrismated in three days. Met. Jonah even spent a half-hour with me to discuss with me what he thought to get out of this conference. I’m ashamed to say that I had no camera to commemorate my experience. His Eminence is a very gentle soul; I can see how determined he is to bring the orthodox Anglicans back into the flock. And onto that. It’s my opinion that there is absolutely no hope for my Catholic Anglican brothers under the leadership of Archbishop Duncan.
During the main event, so to speak, Duncan acknowledged the list of items within Anglicanism that Met. Jonah told him were neither Catholic nor Apostolic. To quote David Virtue’s article on the ACNA Plano conference.
What would it take for this reconciliation to occur? The Metropolitan was explicit:.
Full affirmation of the orthodox Faith of the Apostles and Church Fathers, the seven Ecumenical Councils, the Nicene Creed in its original form (without the filioque clause inserted at the Council of Toledo, 589 A.D.), all seven Sacraments and a rejection of ‘the heresies of the Reformation.”
His Beatitude listed these in a series of ‘isms’; Calvinism, anti-sacramentalism, iconoclasm and Gnosticism. The ordination of women to the Presbyterate and their consecration as Bishops has to end if intercommunion is to occur.
Duncan’s response, ironically, was this: we have to talk about it, we’ll grow, we’ll be in conversation, and will be stretched. Are not these the words that all the ACNA folks accused 815 of using when they wanted to politically state ‘we’re going to beat you over the head until you agree with us’? Homosexual ordination’s wrong? We’re still in discussion about that. Jesus isn’t unique to our salvation? We’re in a listening process, and we’re going to be stretched. So the OCA says to ACNA ‘you need to stop these things before you can claim to be Catholic’ and Duncan says ‘we have to talk about it, we have to consult the others in Anglicanism.’ That means that in order to accept Catholic teaching, Duncan appealed to catholicity to approve said teaching!
During question time I was able to ask Abp. Duncan about how he felt this conversation was going to go, and what his plans were to make the conversation happen. He dodged this bullet like Neo on the Matrix, and talked about God moving in them and the feelings involved, etc. As a matter of fact, there were many Anglicans who were very interested in an Orthodox/Anglican merger that asked Abp. Duncan about merging, and he managed to sidestep and equivocate every chance he had. Thankfully His Eminence provided the meat of the talk. He essentially responded to Abp. Duncan’s flowery rhetoric with ‘yes, but’ statements, bringing it back on topic.
Essentially the meeting was a mix of anger and hope. I still feel the pain of not being in communion with my brothers anymore. I wish that in a few years it would be different. But any Catholic Anglican who will watch the video of the conference, or read the transcripts will know that they have got a very, very long time to go. His Eminence did make mention that he’s been talking to many different continuing Anglican entities, though, so perhaps there remains some hope.
Jenny, Adeline, and will be chrismated and received in three days – this Wednesday at 6:15. Please pray for us.